CHINA / Impact
Weighing pandemic's impact
By MICHAEL R. SESIT (The Wall Street Journal)
Updated: 2005-11-25 12:46
PARIS -- If avian flu sparks a global flu pandemic, the world will have a
lot more to care about than financial markets. But that hasn't stopped
economists and strategists ruminating over the possible impact on
everything from economic growth to interest rates to stock prices and
foreign exchange.
Concerns about a possible pandemic have risen with the emergence of the
H5N1 bird-flu virus, which has jumped from birds to humans, killing 67
people in Asia in the past two years. Some scientists fear that if the
virus mutates to the point where it can be transmitted between humans,
the world could face a pandemic.
"While it is difficult to quantify the precise likelihood of a human H5N1
pandemic, analysis suggests that avian flu is a rising risk to the global
economic outlook," says Robert Bonte-Friedheim, an equity analyst at
Citigroup specializing in medical affairs and lead author of a recent
report on avian flu.
The prospect of that is still viewed as extremely low. But the World
Health Organization estimates that a relatively mild global flu outbreak
could cost two million to seven million lives. But others contend that a
truly virulent virus could rival the 1918-1919 "Spanish flu" in which
anywhere from 20 million to 100 million people died.
"The bottom line is that flu pandemics have already developed in the past
and may well show up again in the future, with potentially devastating
consequences for the global economy and markets," says Lorenzo Codogno,
co-head of European economics at Bank of America.
A relatively mild -- and containable -- outbreak of bird flu would likely
slow economic activity, cause stocks to fall, bonds to rally and trigger
sharp jumps in so-called haven currencies, such as the Swiss franc and
possibly the U.S. dollar and sterling. But these effects should prove
temporary, contend Citigroup analysts. In fact, they regard the equity
selloff as an opportunity to buy stocks that would be expected to rebound
with economic growth.
A full-blown pandemic is another story. Even people who regard
predictions of a repeat of 1918-1919 as alarmist acknowledge the ruinous
impact of such an event. "A virulent, global outbreak of avian flu, which
is still considered to be a low-probability event, would cause global
economic activity to decline, raw-material prices to collapse, risk
aversion to rise, monetary policy to ease and interest rates to fall,"
says Ben Walker, a fund manager at Gartmore Investment Management.
Economies would be buffeted by curtailed individual travel, increased
absenteeism from the workplace, reduced shopping, a steep drop in
consumer and business confidence and government-imposed quarantines.
Meanwhile, the combination of increased investor aversion to risk and
slowing global growth would damp cross-border investment. That, in turn,
should be bad news for the currencies of countries with large
current-account deficits that rely on financing from abroad, such as the
U.S., Australian and New Zealand dollars, the U.K. pound, South African
rand and Mexican peso, says Marvin Barth, a Citigroup currency economist.
Slowing growth, especially in Asia, would also put a big dent in the
demand for raw materials, particularly jet fuel. "Severe constraints on
global mobility will have a huge impact on oil demand," say Citigroup
analysts. "However, some commodities, such as gold and silver, could
benefit from a 'flight-to-quality' trade," says Gartmore's Mr. Walker.
To get a notion of what might happen in various markets, investment
strategists often use the outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome,
or SARS, in 2003 as a template. East Asian growth shrank. Deflation set
in as consumer prices fell in Hong Kong, China and Singapore.
In Hong Kong, tourist arrivals plunged, hotel-occupancy collapsed and the
stock market tumbled 10% in six weeks. Consumer discretionary,
industrial, bank, materials and real-estate stocks in Asian markets
excluding Japan fell 7% to 17%; utilities and health-care stocks rose
slightly. Post-SARS, the sectors that fell the most came roaring back.
Even so, SARS may be too-optimistic a benchmark. It was short-lived and
mostly restricted to four Asian countries.
"In SARS, the market didn't start coming back until the caseload of new
patients was on a sustained downward trend," says Citigroup's Mr.
Bonte-Friedheim. "With a potential H5N1 influenza, it would probably be a
long time before that point is reached."
Under a pandemic scenario, the stock sectors that should perform well
include companies that make antiviral drugs and vaccines, hospital
chains, cleaning-product manufacturers, home-entertainment providers,
telecommunications and Internet-related companies and utilities,
according to Citigroup and Gartmore's Mr. Walker.
Meanwhile, Standard & Poor's notes that "businesses that depend on large
numbers of people congregating -- such as airlines, lodging, leisure and
restaurants -- would suffer serious setbacks." Other "losers" include
shopping-mall operators, luxury-goods companies, oil companies and mining
and metals concerns.
For all the prognosticating though, some contend that such an event would
be so serious that there is little that investors can do. "I don't think
you can do anything about it," warns Crispin Odey, head of Odey Asset
Management in London. "It's uninsurable."
Related Full Coverages
NPC session ends, Premier meets journalists
Premier Wen Jiabao answers questions from foreign and domestic
journalists after the conclusion of the annual session of the National
People's Congress in Beijing March 14, 2006. The annual meeting of the
top lawmaking body closed at the Great Hall of the People. [Xinhua]
UNSC members meet for Iran nuke issue
Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours
� Bird flu control long-term task: Vice Premier
� Top legislature mulls abolishing agricultural tax regulation
� Hebei court hears deadly land dispute case
� Top legislature mulls abolishing agricultural tax regulation
� Top legislature mulls abolishing agricultural tax regulation
Today's Top News
� Putin to talk oil pipeline extension in Beijing
� 'Look at military spending objectively'
� US says no to 'Taiwan independence'
� Environment protection major issue
� US senators to visit China to talk trade issues
Top China News
� FM: Don't politilize illegal immigration issue
� China supports UN human rights body
� 'Be objective on military spending'
� Order Flooring swindles customers - report
� China to press on with reforms: Premier Wen
Learn Chinese
No comments:
Post a Comment